Blog Overview
Choosing between a bathtub and a walk‑in shower depends on your space, lifestyle and future needs — both have pros and cons, so choose what fits you best.
Blog Discussion Points:
- Bathtubs are great for soaking, families and resale appeal
- Walk‑in showers save space, offer accessibility and modern style
- Consider who uses the bathroom and how you use it
- Thoughtfully assess your bathroom size and layout
- You can also combine both if space and budget allow
When planning a bathroom renovation, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is whether to install a bathtub or walk-in shower. Both offer unique benefits, and the right choice often depends on your lifestyle, space, budget, and future needs.
Let’s break down the pros and cons of each to help you decide what’s best for your bathroom—and your day-to-day life.
Bathtubs: Pros and Cons
✅ Pros of a Bathtub
1. Great for Families
If you have young children, a bathtub is incredibly practical. Bath time is easier (and safer) for kids in a tub than in a standing shower.
2. Adds Value for Buyers
In many Australian markets, buyers still expect at least one bathtub in a family home. Even if you prefer showers, having a tub could boost resale value.
3. Perfect for Relaxation
There’s nothing quite like a long soak in a warm bath after a stressful day. For those who prioritise relaxation, a tub is hard to beat.
4. Versatile Designs
From freestanding luxury tubs to compact shower-over-bath combos, there are bathtub options to suit all spaces and styles.
❌ Cons of a Bathtub
1. Takes Up More Space
A standard bathtub requires more floor space than a walk-in shower, making it less ideal for small bathrooms.
2. Water Use
Baths typically use more water than showers, which could lead to higher utility bills and impact sustainability goals.
3. Accessibility Issues
Getting in and out of a bathtub can be difficult for older adults or anyone with limited mobility.
Walk-In Showers: Pros and Cons
✅ Pros of a Walk-In Shower
1. Saves Space
Walk-in showers are compact, sleek, and ideal for small bathrooms or ensuites. With custom glass panels or tiling, they can be tailored to any size.
2. Accessibility
A walk-in shower is easy to enter and exit—no step over the tub. They’re also more adaptable to grab bars, shower seats, and other safety features.
3. Easier to Clean
Showers, especially those with frameless glass or tiled walls, are quicker and easier to clean compared to tubs with tight corners.
4. Modern Appeal
Walk-in showers offer a minimalist, high-end aesthetic that many Australian homeowners love. They create a sense of space and flow.
❌ Cons of a Walk-In Shower
1. No Option to Soak
If you enjoy baths, a walk-in shower simply won’t give you the same experience. Some people miss the ritual of a long soak.
2. May Affect Resale (Slightly)
In family homes, the absence of a bathtub might put off some buyers—particularly those with children.
3. Splash Risk
Improperly designed showers can lead to water spilling onto the bathroom floor. A well-installed screen or gradient is essential.
Questions to Ask Yourself Before Deciding
1. Who Will Be Using the Bathroom?
- Families with young children benefit from having at least one bathtub.
- Older adults may prefer the accessibility of a walk-in shower.
2. How Much Space Do You Have?
- In a small ensuite, a compact walk-in shower might be the only feasible option.
- In a larger main bathroom, you might be able to fit both—or choose freely.
3. What’s Your Daily Routine?
- Do you prefer quick showers or long, relaxing baths?
- Is the bathroom mainly used for getting ready in a rush, or for winding down?
4. Are You Renovating for Now or the Future?
- If you’re planning to age in place, a walk-in shower may offer better long-term practicality.
- If you’re renovating to sell, consider what your local property market values most.
Can You Have Both?
Yes! If space and budget allow, many Australian homeowners opt for a shower-over-bath combo—a great middle ground.
Alternatively, you could include a walk-in shower in the ensuite and a bathtub in the main bathroom. This approach caters to all needs without sacrificing lifestyle preferences.
Styling Tips for Each Option
For Bathtubs:
- Freestanding tubs create a statement in large bathrooms.
- In smaller bathrooms, a built-in tub with storage ledges maximises space.
- Add a bath caddy, candles, and soft lighting for spa-like vibes.
For Walk-In Showers:
- Frameless glass panels make the space feel open and modern.
- Go for floor-to-ceiling tiles for a luxe hotel look.
- Use a rain shower head or dual shower rails for extra comfort.
A Quick Note on Renovation Planning
Whether you go with a tub, a shower, or both—installation must be done properly. Waterproofing, drainage, tiling, and plumbing all need to meet Australian standards. Working with professionals experienced in Bathroom Renovations ensures your upgrade is safe, functional, and beautiful.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why would I choose a bathtub over a walk‑in shower?
A bathtub is ideal if you enjoy long soaks, have young children who need a tub to bathe, or want to boost resale appeal in a family‑home market. It offers comfort and relaxation, and many buyers still expect one bath in the home.
Why might a walk‑in shower be the better choice?
A walk‑in shower works best if you’re short on space, want easy accessibility (especially for older adults or mobility‑impaired users), or simply prefer quick showers to baths. It gives a sleek, modern look and can make the bathroom feel more open.
How do I decide based on how much space I have?
In a small bathroom or ensuite, a walk‑in shower may be the only practical option because it takes up less room. If your bathroom is large enough you might fit both a tub and a shower, giving you flexibility and the best of both worlds.
What should I think about if I plan to stay in my home for many years?
Think about how your needs might change with age or mobility. If you’d like to stay long term or accommodate older residents, a walk‑in shower with low entry, grab bars and seating is often a smarter long‑term investment.
Does replacing a bathtub with a walk‑in shower affect resale value?
It can. In homes geared toward families, removing the only bathtub might reduce appeal to buyers with children. However, in many markets walk‑in showers are highly desirable for their modern look and accessibility. If space allows, having both is the most market‑friendly solution.
Final Thoughts
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The best choice depends on how you use your bathroom, who uses it, and what kind of lifestyle you want to support.
- Go with a bathtub if you love to relax, have kids, or want to increase your home’s family appeal.
- Choose a walk-in shower if you’re after convenience, space-saving, and a modern design.
Still unsure? A professional can assess your space and recommend a layout that balances comfort, style, and functionality.
Let Jim’s Handyman Help You Decide
Need help installing a walk-in shower or replacing your old tub? Jim’s Handyman has the experience and tools to get the job done right. From minor updates to full bathroom transformations, we’re here to make your renovation smooth and stress-free.
👉 Contact Jim’s Handyman today and let’s bring your dream bathroom to life—whether it includes a luxurious bath, a sleek shower, or both!
Related articles you might be interested in: